This week on the podcast, we attempt no small task: to bring together neurobiology and Jungian thought to explore the possible evolutionary roots of the mother archetype. Jungian analyst Lisa Marchiano welcomes back GARY CLARK, author of Carl Jung and the Evolutionary Sciences and a visiting research fellow at the University of Adelaide.
Understanding the Mother Archetype
When a new mother cradles an infant, the mother archetype is constellated. Maternal instinct means previously unknown behaviors now feel completely natural: crooning to the baby in a singsong voice, cradling her on the left side, rocking her gently to sleep. This shows up in the culture in the endless representations of the mother archetype – such as the Madonna and child – in art, religion and literature.
Jungian vs Evolutionary Understandings: How Similar Are They?
Jungians explain such maternal experiences as universal patterns of behavior that organize psychic energy related to mothering. Science, on the other hand, presents us with evidence pointing to ancient parts of the brain and the role of oxytocin. These positions are not necessarily in opposition; both camps see ancient patterns emerging in the individual. Jung himself had a strong intuition that our evolutionary past could be a powerful explanation for many aspects of our psychology. He even proposed that archetypes are located in subcortical brain systems, in evolutionary terms the most ancient parts of the brain and brain stem.
How Mothering Shaped the Human Race
It is possible that the demands of caring for a helpless infant shaped some of our most distinctive human capacities. We discuss, for example, suggestions that the singsong exchanges between mothers and babies may have helped lay the groundwork for music and language.
Join us as we range freely through primatology, archaeology, neurobiology, and psychoanalytic history, asking what the mother archetype and the work of caring for infants might tell us about how we became human.
Our Guest – Gary Clark
Gary Clark is a visiting research fellow at Adelaide University’s School of Medicine. Since 2012, he has been a member of School’s Biological Anthropology and Comparative Anatomy Unit. His research focus includes the evolution of music, palaeoanthropology and evolutionary approaches to analytical psychology.If you’re interested in Gary’s work, we highly recommend his book Carl Jung and the Evolutionary Sciences. You can find his academic papers on academia.edu and ResearchGate.
Resources from the Episode
- William H. Calvin, The Throwing Madonna: Essays on the Brain
- Gary Clark, Carl Jung and the Evolutionary Sciences.
- Dean Falk, Finding Our Tongues: Mothers, Infants, and the Origins of Language
- James Fernandez, Bwiti: An Ethnography of the Religious Imagination in Africa.
- Erik Goodwyn, “Archetypes and the ‘Impoverished Genome’ argument: updates from evolutionary genetics”, Journal of Analytical Psychology, November 2020.
- Chris Knight, Blood Relations: Menstruation and the Origins of Culture.
- Thomas T. Lawson, Carl Jung, Darwin of the Mind.
- Iain McGilchrist, The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World.
- Erich Neumann, The Origins and History of Consciousness.
Related Episodes
If you’ve enjoyed this episode, we recommend these related conversations:
