pixel

WELCOME TO Module 1

Dreamwork Can Change Your Life

Our exploration of dreams and dreaming will begin at the beginning.

Dreams are fascinating, mysterious – and often beautiful. They can be humorous, frightening, and strange. But is it worth it to pay attention to them?

Obviously, we think the answer is yes.

In addition to being inspiring aesthetic masterpieces, dreams can guide us, haunt us, or even point us down a different road.

“An uninterpreted dream is like an unopened letter.”

THE TALMUD

THE DISCUSSION

Why working with your dreams is important

Dreams always tell us something we don’t already know.
Dreams are part of how the psyche self-regulates.
Dreams aid in the individuation process and connect us with the Self.
Dreams help the dreamer create an alliance with and access to the unconscious.
Dreams are the easiest way to access the unconscious.
Dreams support healing and wholeness by building up ego capacity.
Dreams can be diagnostic.
Dreams can indicate a corrective to a life course.
Dreams provide access to the collective unconscious and emerging myth and meaning.

NB: Notes on dreams referenced in the Discussion can be read at the beginning of the transcript below.

Read the transcript

THIS JUNGIAN LIFE DREAM SCHOOL

Lisa Marchiano, Jungian Analyst, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Joseph Lee, Jungian Analyst, Virginia Beach, Virginia Deborah Stewart, Jungian Analyst, Cape Cod, Massachusetts

__________________________________________________________________

Module 1: Dreamwork Can Change Your life

EDITED TRANSCRIPT

Joseph: All three of us have personal, lived, proof that working with our dreams and those of others changes lives. Long before any of us were analysts, we were working with our own inner material, bringing it to our analysts and discovering guidance that could inspire us in moving forward. Dreams protected us and warned us when we were off the path. They were and are a self-correcting and befriending mechanism inside each of us. That is the gold and treasure of working with dreams.

Lisa: I didn’t work with my dreams simply because they were fascinating and beautiful. I was drawn to work with my dreams because there was a problem in my life I hadn’t been able to solve in any other way. I had tried all kinds of practical, ego-oriented ways to solve the problem, and it was still there. This led me to turn inward to my dreams–I thought, what the heck, what have I got to lose? Who knows? Maybe there’s something in my inner world that can help.

Deb: That was my experience, too. I was at a low point in my life–midlife, of course, the exact time Jung was especially interested in, though I didn’t know that at the time. I decided to try therapy in addition to everything else, such as visiting friends, starting an exercise program, and more. My analyst suggested that we work with dreams and although I thought that sounded a bit far out, at least one of us had a game plan. I found in working with dreams over time that I developed a relationship with them and with myself in ways that I truly had not known existed. Jung says that we don’t solve our problems, we outgrow them–I got bigger and my problems got proportionally smaller. Working with dreams expands us into parts of ourselves that we just can’t meet in waking life.

Lisa: Working with dreams opens a whole new register.

Deb: Yes, dreams open a whole new domain, a big part of us that often has a very different perspective and sees things very differently from the way that consciousness perceives them. Dream work is also

readily accessible–we dream several times every night, so each of us has a ready path to expansion, depth, and more wholeness.

Joseph: Just as you said, Deb, the dream maker sees things differently. The waking personality naturally has a kind of resistance to the “medicine” of the dream, and that can interfere with engaging our dreams. An integral part of dream work is facing things we have not seen about ourselves.

Lisa: Our renowned colleague, Jim Hollis, says a primary reason we work with dreams is because they don’t come from the ego. I think that touches into exactly what you were saying, Joseph: dreams provide us with the perspective of the unconscious. That is not necessarily better than the conscious perspective, but it is different, and our egos can be averse to it–but if we’re not tending to dreams, we’re missing this whole realm and a totally different perspective on our problems. Although it is completely alien to the conscious way of viewing our lives, it adds information and offers an attitude our conscious mind just doesn’t have. That’s why, despite having tried so many things, I couldn’t solve my life problem with ego-oriented tools. The richness of dreams is available to any of us at any time. If we work with dreams we discover what “the rest of us” has to say about our problems, triumphs, or questions. Why not find out?

Deb: Yes, and picking up on Joseph’s point about our resistance, dreams are often commentary about our ego attitude toward life, toward work, or how things “should” be. My dreams back then were saying, “that’s not how I see it, lady,” and I was resistant to that. I was having a hard enough time as it was and I didn’t want extra challenges. Besides, some of the images and implications of my dreams were interesting, but puzzling and far from helpful in any practical way. My first dream was of being in the nave of a Catholic church. I had only been in a Catholic church once, and I had no conscious idea what a nave even was. So, although the imagery was intriguing, I couldn’t experience the dream in a way that felt real, let alone related to my career and life crisis. On the other hand, I felt oddly hopeful and interested–the utterly unexpected image in that dream was undeniable evidence of life outside consciousness and in me even if I didn’t understand it—yet. Our dreams don’t usually come and hit us over the head, but they do open something up that adds to consciousness and waking life. And by the way, a full understanding of that supposedly weird dream, when it later arrived, was amazing.

Joseph: My initiation into the power of dream work started when I had a disturbing, recurring dream. I had just moved to Virginia Beach, and was living alone, which I hadn’t done for a long time. I began to have dreams that someone had broken into the ground floor of my townhouse and was walking up the stairs. I heard them, and when they got to the top of the stairs, I reached into a bed stand, retrieved a pistol, and shot them. This dream was unlike any dream I’d ever had. Like any number of dreams, I might have dismissed it or not paid much attention to it, but this dream started repeating, night after night. Then, even more disturbingly, I began to daydream about the event–even when I was stopped

at a red light. It occurred to me to mention this to one of my new friends, who was part of the local Jung society. I was just starting out on my psychological journey, and this person suggested that I go back into the dream and speak to the intruder. I had been meditating for quite a while but it had never occurred to me to re-enter a dream and work that way. So, after putting myself in a meditative state, I replayed the dream, and when the intruder came to the top of the stairs, I asked him what he was here to teach me. He took me on a long walk and gave me frank, life-changing advice about things I just hadn’t been paying attention to. After that—a process I later learned is called active imagination–I never had the dream again. My career and personal life improved over the next several months in a way that was directly related to the information my supposed intruder provided.

Lisa: That is so dramatic and compelling. I imagine that you were sold at that point on the power of dream work. We’ve all had powerful experiences working with our own dreams, and we’ve certainly seen the value of working with dreams with clients.

Joseph: Another example of the power that a single dream can have is from an early period in my practice, when I was working with younger people. I was counselling a girl who was about 14 years old with a complaint about intense performance anxiety. Understandably, there was a lot of pressure, but she began to experience extended periods of crippling insomnia. She had tried all kinds of ways to improve sleep, and was even considering medication, but nothing was changing. After we had been working together for several weeks, I suspected there was something more going on in her life, and she told me she dreamed of walking into a room where her mom and dad were watching TV. She sat down to join them and experienced volcanic anger erupting. She faced her mom and really let loose and lambasted her. She told her mom everything she was angry about and let fly all the criticisms she didn’t have the courage to say in waking life. When she was finally exhausted, the dream mother was understanding, compassionate, and heart-centered–very different from how this girl had been experiencing her mother in waking life. We were then able to talk more directly about what was getting under her skin, and once she was able to vent some of her anger, she could access positive feelings about her mom. Most importantly, the months of agonizing insomnia immediately resolved: that night she went home and slept like a baby. Her anger toward her mother had been so dangerous to her conscious attitude that it had been buried. The dream maker finally manufactured a volcano of feeling she couldn’t ignore, and once that anger was expressed and accepted, her body was able to relax and she could sleep. With the benefit of sleeping normally, her anxiety went down, her physical coordination improved, and her performance in competitions got better with less anxiety. We couldn’t have anticipated all these things, and they emanated from a dream.

Deb: That really illustrates how dreams connect us with feelings. They give us scenes, people and emotion, including experiences of wonder and befriending. It might be a deer that comes up on the back porch and wants to be touched, or a snowy owl sitting on a branch in the moonlight. Or it might

be a kind of magical feeling of being in a foreign country, walking on cobblestone streets, and looking in charming shops and an old cathedral. One person who was going through a particularly painful time heard a voice in a dream say “you are loved.” The unconscious is our companion, and comes toward us in many ways. It can release emotion, just like it did for the teenage girl, it can open new worlds and experiences, it can reassure us, and it can fill us with profound new awareness, like your dream of the intruder. I believe that no matter what the feeling is, we wake up having experienced something we need to know.

Lisa: I have an analogy: for most of my life, I wasn’t really interested in birdsong, but about 10 years ago, I started noticing it and getting curious about which bird was making which sound. As I learned more and paid more attention, I realized there was a wealth of information outside on any given day; it had been around me all the time, but I’d never really noticed. Once I started noticing it was rich, beautiful, and fascinating. The chickadee call, for example, is a warning. They’re transmitting information to one another about the size and nature of a threat. When you walk outside and you hear “chicadeedee,” they’re probably talking about you, although you’re not a big threat because you’re slow moving and on the ground. But if there’s a hawk in the neighborhood, they increase the “deedeedee” at the end of their note, so you can suddenly understand the intensity of the threat, including whether they’re talking about you. You can hear the house wren making quite a mighty noise for a small bird—it’s advertising its nesting place to a potential mate. There’s abundant information right outside that you walk past every day. Noticing birdsong is very much like realizing the rich information in your dreams, taking an interest, and beginning to understand it.

Deb: I really like that analogy, Lisa. It’s so apt, and it also points to the difference between how Jung and Freud saw dreams. Freud thought that dreams were a disguise, protecting sleep by wrapping illicit sexual urges into less disturbing images. The implication was that dreams were essentially negative, so the dreamer had to be protected from raw, unconscious material—but Jung realized that dreams aren’t a disguise. Dreams simply use an archaic language of image and symbol—a different kind of information, like birdsong. Today, as modern people, we’ve all but forgotten this language, so much of Jung’s work was how to translate dreams into consciousness and meaning. Fairy tales do this too. Sometimes they image archaic aspects of the psyche as animals, the wise old woman in the woods, a sorcerer, or other familiar types of characters. Fairy tales are the dreams of the human collective, and they lift up the wisdom of the unconscious in the surprising events that they depict. This Jungian Life Dream School is essentially about learning the language of the unconscious, and we use fairy tales as well as dreams and mythology–all are forms of the ancient, original language of psyche.

Lisa: Speaking of fairy tales and learning another language, there’s a Brothers Grimm tale about learning the language of the animals, which we could think about as the voice of the unconscious. The story, The White Snake, provides a metaphor for what it’s like to work with dreams. Every day at noon,

a covered dish was placed on the king’s table. The king would eat alone from this dish, and nobody in the entire realm knew what kind of food was in it. One of the servants became curious and wanted to know what the dish contained. One day after the king ordered him to take the dish away, the servant took the dish to his room and uncovered it. As he lifted the cover, he found a white snake lying inside, and he felt a great desire to taste it, so he cut off a piece and began eating it. As soon as his tongue touched the flesh of the snake, he understood the language of the animals and heard the birds on the windowsill speaking to each other. That day, the queen lost one of her most beautiful rings and suspicion fell on him. The king said that if the servant was not able to find the thief by morning, he would be punished as the guilty one.

The servant became sad and went to the courtyard where some ducks were resting in the water, and he heard one of them say, “there’s something heavy in my stomach. I have a ring that the queen lost.” The servant took the duck and carried it to the cook, saying, “kill this one. It’s fat enough.” The cook cut the duck’s neck, and when he began cleaning it, found the queen’s ring lying in its stomach. The servant brought it to the king who was astonished and happy. Since he was sorry that he had treated the servant unjustly, the king said, “Demand whatever reward you would like or any position of royal honor you desire.” The servant declined, for his heart was sad and he didn’t want to remain in court any longer. He asked only for a horse and money to travel and see the world. He was provided with everything and rode off the next morning.

He came to a pond with three fish trapped in the reeds, wailing that they would die if they couldn’t get back into open water. He dismounted, freed them from the reeds and released them into the water. The fish cried out, “We will remember you, and we will one day repay you.” He rode on, and a while later he heard an ant king crying up, “get away from us. Your enormous beast is trampling us with his large hooves.” The young man looked down and saw that his horse had stepped on an anthill, so he turned his horse away. The ant king called out, “We will remember you and will one day repay you.” Soon the servant entered a forest where two ravens were throwing their young ones out of their nests. They said their fledglings were big enough to feed themselves. The little birds lay on the ground, lamenting that they would die from starvation because they couldn’t yet fly in search of food. The young man dismounted, killed his horse with a sword, and offered it to the young ravens. They hopped over to the horse, ate their fill, and said, “We will remember this and will one day repay you.”

The young man walked on and came to a large city where he heard a proclamation that whoever wanted to marry the king’s daughter could do so by carrying out a task set by her, but if the would-be suitor failed, he would forfeit his life. Many princes had already tried and lost their lives, so the opportunity to seek the princess’ hand was now open to anyone. The servant thought about it and decided to declare himself a suitor. He was led out to sea, a ring was thrown into the water and his task was to fetch it. If he failed to retrieve the ring, he’d be taken into the deeps to drown. As he stood on the shore, the three fish he had saved from the reeds swam toward him. One of the fish held a shell in its mouth. The fish set it down to the suitor’s feet, and in the shell was the ring. Full of joy, he brought the ring to the king and demanded the princess as his wife.

However, when the princess heard that he wasn’t a prince, she refused to accept him. She then scattered 10 sacks of millet seeds in the grass and ordered the unknown man to pick them all up before sunrise. Every single grain was to be gathered or he would lose his life. As he stood there, the ant king arrived with all the ants the young man had saved. They gathered the millet seeds during the night, put them into sacks, and by morning, the task was finished. When the princess saw that the sacks had been filled, she was astonished, and asked that the young man be brought before her. Since he was handsome, she liked him, but she demanded that he perform a third task. He was now to fetch an apple from the tree of life. Once again, he stood there wondering how to accomplish the task, and one of the ravens he had fed arrived with the apple in its beak. The princess now found the young man worthy of becoming her husband, and when her father died, he became king.

The animals in the story represent the wisdom of seemingly lowly life—like a simple-seeming dream–and the need for humility and receptivity as the prerequisite for later empowerment. Working with dreams also restores our ability to hear the subtle voice of instinctual wisdom. We all have access to it, and the fairy tale is a wonderful metaphor for the gifts the unconscious can offer us if we learn how to listen to our dreams. What’s important about the servant on his adventure is that he listens to a tiny ant, and this stands him in very good stead as he seeks his fortune. Killing his horse to feed the ravens is much more difficult, and represents sacrificing his ego-oriented attitude in service to the unconscious. In return, a raven eventually brings him an apple from the tree of life, something of transcendent value. The tale is a wonderful metaphor for why we work with dreams. It brings about a change in attitude, a reorientation to life that goes beyond ego. Our life quest, like that of the servant in the tale, is to gain what Jung called “the treasure hard to attain”–the wholeness that can come only through a relationship with the unconscious. We created This Jungian Life Dream School to teach people the secret language of our inner animals, those parts of ourselves we haven’t been able to hear or understand.

Joseph: Just like the hero in the fairy tale, we can all learn to hear our inner fish, notice the tiny ants working industriously below, and a cheeky raven poking around our inner landscape. Unfamiliar parts of us speak every night, and the language of animals is like body language. A dream that changed someone’s life came through her body. I was working with a middle-aged woman who was successful and respected. She was a wise woman in the community and had come mostly out of curiosity. She told me a dream fragment in which she was walking in her childhood home, crossing the balcony above the living room. She noticed that everyone was very quiet, and initially just accepted it. She repeated crossing the balcony a few times and then she woke up. That’s the kind of dream that doesn’t sound at all extraordinary, but something tapped on my intuition. Before I was the therapist, I was an Alexander Technique teacher, so it occurred to me to ask her to demonstrate walking on the balcony. She walked back and forth across my office a few times, and I noticed that she was walking on the balls of her feet like a ballerina, stepping forward, touching her toes, and rolling back to her heel in a very stylized manner. I said, “It looks like you’re walking so you don’t make any noise,” and her body began to quiver with an upwelling of feeling. She sat on the floor and wept. When her body calmed down, she

recalled that when she was a teen, her father became obsessed with the sound of her walking and would shout that she was like a horse. It created so much anxiety that she began teaching herself how to walk carefully and softly so she could not be heard. As young people, if we find ourselves in a difficult situation, our instincts tell us how to accommodate to stay safe, and sometimes that anxiety can get stored in an aspect of the unconscious that reaches into the body. This was finally a time to grieve that. After we discussed this a few times, her gait changed and we noticed that she was walking more naturally and less self-consciously, doing a normal heel strike and rolling through her feet. There was rhythm and cadence in her body that also relieved chronic hip pain. So the language of birds and the body—and dreams–often speaks in small ways that can let us in on important secrets.

Deb: This woman’s dream seemed so flat and ordinary–she was just walking back and forth across a balcony–yet working with the dream unlocked something important that the dream maker wanted her to access: the feeling that she couldn’t afford to have as a teen. It was still there, and by accessing it through her dream, she had more life, more energy in her stride, and less pain in her hip. Something traumatic was lifted off. I’m thinking along a similar line about a woman who had a memory that was not entirely obvious in her dream but had great meaning. This woman had a dream in which she was celebrating what seemed to be her 16th birthday. There was a cake and 16 candles, but she was all alone in the dream and felt very sad as she blew the out the candles. We talked about how blowing out birthday candles doesn’t usually create sadness, and that family events during her teens had been difficult. Shortly after this dream an uncle died, and this woman received a box of letters he had saved from family members. She discovered she had been separated from her mother for about eight weeks when she was 16 months old, and the dream maker had wanted to reconnect her with early absence and loneliness. People often dream about being a younger age, such as I was in high school, and dreams of a younger time in life can spark memories and feelings that we couldn’t fully experience then. Dreams like this provide meaning, relief, and healing.

Joseph: Deb, that speaks beautifully to the integrative function of dreams and the way they help us connect the life of the unconscious with the waking personality—and that quite literally makes us more whole. We can’t resist telling people about dreams that have had a dramatic effect on us, and I think most people can recall at least one dream that had a powerful impact on their lives. But I also want to give a shout-out to dreams that simply provide color, nuance, and commentary that’s useful– gentle course correction that’s applicable to our day-to-day lives. A dream that was not especially remarkable, but useful, featured me driving to my office, as I do every day. All the traffic lights on the road were red. Again, and again, I stopped and began to feel frustrated that a fast commute was taking more and more time. I was incredulous that I was hitting red light after red light. Something about the dream stuck with me as I was going through my work day, and I realized it was a gentle, needed message telling me to slow down, take a break–hit the brakes, sit for 30 seconds, listen to the radio and relax–something I was forgetting to do.

Deb: That’s an example of how a seemingly ordinary dream can have something important to tell us. Dreams like that are like the ants in the fairy tale—they seem hardly worthy of notice, except, of course, they are. This sparks a memory for me of a dream I had many years ago. When I awoke, I couldn’t believe that I had spent what seemed like hours in the dream doing housework. I was aghast that what I did during my waking life I was also doing at night. As the day went on, I found myself amused in an ironic kind of way, and had a chance to share the dream with a friend. Just as you said, we love to tell people our dreams, so I started telling her I was in the upstairs bathroom cleaning the shower and then I was vacuuming dust bunnies under this bed…I was dusting, putting away toys, doing the laundry and folding towels—and suddenly we both started laughing and she gasped, “Okay, enough, no more”! I said, “No, I didn’t get to the part where I was cleaning out the cutlery drawer.” I think the dream maker wanted me to lighten up!

Joseph: I love the homey way that this dream provided a trickster dynamic to balance an overly serious attitude. Dreams can jostle us around. My red-light dream and your housework dream fall into this category–and the dream maker is interested in the mundane aspects of our lives. It helps us all the time. I also remember that when I was rehabbing my new house, which needed a huge amount of work, I was thankful that I often dreamed about details I had overlooked. They were significant, and it gave me the feeling that the dream maker was supervising my effort to learn some basic carpentry. It felt like somebody was looking out for me and had my back.

Deb: This takes me to another way of imagining dream work: it’s like beachcombing. I live on Cape Cod and with beachcombing there’s a reverie–you never know what will have been washed up by the great unconscious called the ocean. When you’re beachcombing you’re in an in-between state: alert and scanning, but with quietude–not altogether an ego state. A man who was considering retirement dreamed that he was walking on the beach and saw something sticking up in the sand. He was curious so he stopped, lifted it up, and saw that it was a sea turtle’s shell. He rinsed the sand out and then noticed there was an image on the inside of the shell. He cleaned the interior of the shell with some sand, gently rubbing some of the detritus away, revealing a photographic image of a living room. It was a lovely image of wholeness, the man-made living room and the natural “living room” of a turtle. The beachcombing in his dream endorsed his readiness to be his own home.

Lisa: I like the image of beachcombing. It is a little bit like my birdsong analogy. In that note, if you’re not paying attention, you walk right past all kinds of treasures. If you’re walking on the beach with a friend and you’re talking or focused on getting your 10,000 steps in, you’re not in the right state of mind to notice. If you slow down and cast your eyes on the sand, you find treasures. I remember I once found a tiny bird’s egg that was perfectly intact in the sand. I love finding those wonderful egg casings for the little conch shells–if you hold them up to the light or break them open, there are thousands of

tiny shells inside. There are all manner of fascinating, surprising things on beaches. The treasures are there, and all it takes to see them is to shift your attitude. I think that’s what we’re encouraging in This Jungian Life Dream School: slow down and let your eyes and ears scan for the treasures that enrich you. There is wisdom in the unconscious, and listening to it will alter the course of your life, though not usually in a flashy, dramatic way. As you work with dreams you open a channel between the conscious personality and the guiding center that Jung referred to as the Self. The big idea that undergirds dreamwork is that it’s a way to commune with this wiser, larger part of you.

Joseph: There’s a quality of attention—memory, beachcombing, or birdsong. Sometimes it’s a haunting fairy tale theme. Over and over and again, change can come in tiny moments of noticing and relating. In the fairy tale, it’s like the young man is getting off his high horse. Whether it’s helping fish out of the weeds, stepping off an anthill, or the painful sacrifice of a horse, there is a substantive, reliable form of life in the psyche that sees and feeds potentials. There’s a recurring message to slow down, embrace a spirit of receptivity and humility, and befriend what is encountered, even if it seems small or requires sacrificing the ego attitude. The life of the psyche is often conveyed through ordinary images, and little by little, time after time, this connects us with the guiding Self, our true center.

Lisa: There is a kind of incremental quality to dream work. Most of our dreams can be compared to freeing the fish or sparing the ants. Once receptivity has been established, it’s as if the dream maker can then send bigger messages, like killing the ego’s “horse” for the sake of something larger. The following dream is an example of that. This man always had a rational, ego-oriented way of moving through the world. He worked in a profession that required him to have a scientific, objective focus. Midlife challenged him to get in touch with parts of himself that he had neglected, and he entered analysis and began working with his dreams. Then he had a big dream. He was hiking up a snowy mountain with younger people, saw that they had reached a plateau, and was scrambling up the snowy slope to reach it. He started to slip and then he fell. Below was a cliff, and far below that was an icy wasteland–nothing as far as the eye could see. When he began falling through the air he thought, I don’t know if I will survive this and even if I do, I don’t think I can be rescued. He fell to what he thought would be his death, and then woke up as a quadriplegic in hospital. A young, robust man was his physical therapist, and he gathered the dreamer lovingly in his arms and sat him beside a pool. They were talking and with the dreamer’s consent, the therapist put him in a special chair so the dreamer could sit in the water. Then the therapist tipped the chair over backwards into the water. The dreamer was plunged into the pool headfirst, sputtering and panicked, but he somehow made it to the side of the pool. Then he pulled himself out and was overjoyed, because he realized he would be able to learn to walk again. The dream told him that with some help, he would be able to restore feeling and come alive. The profound imagery in this dream had a very big effect on the dreamer.

Deb: This dream illustrates how the dream ego’s orientation, which often mirrors our waking life ego, is sometimes very wrong from the dream maker’s point of view. One might think struggling up a mountain is a positive endeavor, and that it would be awful to push a quadriplegic into a pool–yet that was exactly what the dreamer needed. He needed to wake up to the realization that what seemed disastrous was actually the medicine, and he woke up with a radical reorientation to life.

Lisa: The dream was deeply reassuring, because I think he feared there was nothing other than striving to climb the icy mountains of life, fall into a wasteland, or be paralyzed. He didn’t know what else was in him. He hadn’t had a direct experience of that part of himself imaged by the physical therapist in the dream, who could be seen as this man’s actual outer analyst and his inner therapist.

Deb: Yes, what the dream ego thought was awful turned out to be liberating, and this new attitude is an epiphany, a surprising new possibility. That’s exactly what happens in fairy tales, which also emanate from the unconscious. In the fairy tale you read, Lisa, the first reaction to the hero killing his horse is horror, but the counter-intuitive event is what provides the opening to the apple from the tree of life. Fairy tales and dreams show that psyche is befriending us, but sometimes it does so in ways contradictory to ego attitudes. Jung’s famous saying is that a defeat for the ego is a victory for the Self, and in this dream being dumped into the pool—panic-inducing for the dream ego–assures the needed renewal from the guiding center.

Joseph: All this shows how vividly dreams can reconnect us in an experiential way to capacities of self that have been forgotten. We may hear about “green,” for example, but that doesn’t help us see it. Some psychological “receptor sites” may have become locked storehouses for painful feelings, but the dream maker considers them important aspects of our potential. Like in the dream you just related, Lisa, dreams can reintroduce us to life-giving values, attitudes, or ideas. All the examples we’ve provided illustrate the depth of feeling that can be returned to the dreamer, and this is often a critical factor in restoring the life narrative. This reminds me of a powerful experience of a middle-aged guy with a negative mother complex. This was a real burden and generated a lot of resentment that regularly spilled over into various aspects of his life. After some time in analysis he had this dream: he was a little boy, maybe four years old, at the beach with his family. His mother was resting under an umbrella. He went to the ocean, filled a little plastic pail with water, returned, and carefully poured it over his mother’s feet to cool them. As he did this, his mother scowled and shooed him away. When this man awakened, he felt the dream depicted the familiar experience of being dismissed and rejected by his mother. As we continued to talk, he realized that as he was pouring water over his mother’s feet, he felt tenderness and love for her, something he had not felt in decades. The dream returned his capacity to feel loving, and like a receptor site that had been clogged, something opened. The positive aspect of the mothering principle was re-experienced, and proved that abuse had not blighted his

capacity to offer love. That restoration changed his emotional trajectory, which is what Jung meant by a new attitude.

Lisa: Dreams affect our lives. All the examples we’ve shared tell us something fundamental about what it means to be human and feel more enlivened. This makes me think of another important aspect of dreams: both the dream I shared earlier about the man scrambling up the mountain and the dream that you just shared, Joseph, have a profound spiritual aspect. Sometimes I feel that dreams are my religion because they provide direct experiences of the transcendent. In biblical times, dreams were understood as a way God talked to people, and most cultures have honored dreams as the voice of the divine. Today, thanks especially to Jung, we also think of dreams as connecting us with what Jung referred to as the Self, a spiritual center long recognized as something that’s both within us and “other.” It knows the direction of our development and oversees the unfolding of our personality. It places us within a larger cosmic scheme. We all have dreams marked by a wondrous “more” that we did not create that is affirming and reassuring. Your guide is not an abstraction but a personal presence. This divinity is not a theological concept–it happens in your dreams.

Deb: Dreams are experiences. Dreams are not an idea or a thought or a concept. Dreams touch us every night and you, our new This Jungian Life Dream School student, can bring these experiences more and more into waking memory, conscious knowledge, and abiding companionship. We’ll end this introductory segment with an assignment: get a dream journal. Before you go online or race to the store, we ask that you invest this with ritual, the kind of dedication demonstrated by the hero of the fairy tale who got off his horse of ego and reason to free the fish, spare the ants, and feed the ravens. So, like him, undertake this task with your whole being. You can go to a very ordinary store, but your purpose is to choose exactly the right notebook. Pick some up to see which is the right size with the right color cover. Bring it home and have a moment of dedication as you put it on your bedside table with a pen or pencil for recording your dreams. As you get in bed, tell the dream maker, I’m ready to receive any dream you may send and will record it in this journal. Welcome to the inner adventure of dreams.

Musings

Every month, we share our personal reflections based on the month’s module topic. This month, we provide an overview of The Discussion, and share some of our own experiences of dreaming that mattered.

We’ve all had dreams that provided fresh insights at critical junctures.  We recognized the value of dreams and  the need to record and reflect on them years before working with analysands.

 

This month's musings: Our own experiences with dreams

DOWNLOAD HERE

Our Personal Experience with Dreams

We became interested in our own dreams many years before we became therapists. At some point, each of us realized that we could turn to our dreams for guidance and we began writing them down. We share our own experiences with dreams that marked us, altered us, or helped us change course.

 Joseph

I was introduced to Jung’s work serendipitously during my last semester as a Theater undergrad. As a young actor I thought a class in Theories of Human Personality would be helpful in character development. A professor patiently unpacked the complicated systems of modern American personality theorists. I found memorizing the disjointed lists of ideas exhausting until we began reading Jung, whose intuitive style of building meaning, layer upon layer, captured my imagination. Jung simmered in the background for a few decades, surfacing in my love of symbolism, archetypes, and dreams.

By my troubled early thirties, I was deep in Hermetic studies, struggling to integrate a particular quality of discernment – an essential stage of spiritual development. This promised to reveal a radiant spirituality beneath outer life. I was focused on the symbolism of the 15th Tarot card The Devil and Qabalistic teachings regarding the Hebrew letter Ayin. I recall reading, “The Devil is God as he appears to the wicked,” which evoked a deep sense of shame. A traumatic childhood had left me in a pervasive atmosphere of dread and armed me with a false certainty that every situation harbored an enemy. My meditations were no match for those foundational wounds – and then I had this dream:

I’m at home late at night. As a severe storm rages outside, I hear loud pounding on the front door. I go to the top of the stairs and think, “This is how horror movies begin.” I slowly descend the stairs and stand by the front door. The pounding has stopped. I open the door with dread. Standing in the rain is a roaring humanoid monster with a disfigured head and an enormous, fanged mouth. I am frozen in fear. As I remain rooted in place, I realize it is roaring in pain and weep with compassion. The monster transforms into a beautiful, peaceful, blonde man. I wonder if he is an angel.

I woke astounded, as if I had passed a trial by fire. I had stood before something terrifying without defaulting to fight or flight, my usual responses. Instead, compassion appeared and grace was bestowed. Asleep, I had lived a transformative moment. It would take years before I could invite other exiled parts of myself to the table of consciousness, but this dream provided a glimpse of future possibilities and the encouraging presence I so badly needed at the time.

“Perhaps all the dragons in our lives are princesses who are only waiting to see us act, just once, with beauty and courage. Perhaps everything that frightens us is, in its deepest essence, something helpless that wants our love.”

Rainer Maria Rilke, Letters to a Young Poet

Postscript.

Twenty-five years later I received an unexpected package from a fellow undergrad. Inside was my term paper from the Theories of Personality class; I had asked her to read it in 1985 and she’d saved it all these years. I was gripped by my 21-year-old self as I reread it. My naked disclosures set my face burning as I recounted my associative process triggered by Archetypal images. Descriptions of my negative mother complex flowed across the pages and I marveled at the artfully sensitive comments the professor penned in the margins. At the end he wrote, “You have a talent with the European Schools,” pointing me toward Jung, Freud, and Adler.

Lisa

I “discovered” Jung in 1993. Perhaps I should say “rediscovered.” My mother loved Jung and his books were featured on our bookshelves. When my sister and I were at school, she would sit at home and read the Collected Works. But I had never read anything either by Jung or by a Jungian analyst – until I stumbled upon Linda Leonard’s book, On the Way to the Wedding, during a particularly dark time in my life. The book made a tremendous impact on me. By the time I finished it, I had even had the thought that perhaps I might one day become an analyst. A week or two after finishing the book, I had the following dream:

I’m swimming in the ocean and I’m a little afraid. I’m not out very deep but there is a terrific undertow. There are other people with me. One is a beautiful young woman who is a very accomplished swimmer. She is helping me not to be afraid. She teaches me how not to panic but to go steady and sure, and to always have faith that the ground is not far below. I am standing in the water watching a huge wave that towers over our heads coming toward us. I am afraid but I know that if I duck under the wave, everything will be okay. On the other hand, if I don’t, that’s when I might kick and splutter and get tossed about. I’m anticipating the wave waiting to duck under.

This dream was gifted to me just as I had become interested in my dreams. At a difficult time, the dream offered a comforting “reality check:” despite how bad I thought things were, the ground was not far below. It also offered a prescription for how best to face the quickly rising psychological wave. I would weather it fine if I submitted, whereas resistance would likely bring greater suffering. Perhaps more than anything, the dream offered a comforting image of an inner companion – a beautiful young woman who was a very accomplished swimmer. This positive shadow figure was at home in the depths in a way that my conscious ego was not. She was there to guide and companion me.

The dream was also sobering. Yes, a wave was coming – a wave that could and would wash away many aspects of the life I had been living. In this way, the dream prefigured what was to come over the next several years. I did go on to face a rising tide of doubts about the career to which I had committed. I did venture into the depths with the help of an inner companion and learned how to navigate the swells of emotion and image while maintaining contact with the ground beneath me.

Deb

When I read C. G. Jung’s Memories, Dreams, Reflections as a college sophomore, nothing in his memoir stated or implied anything about “belief” in dreams—or anything else. Jung simply told what had happened to him—a life filled with inner action and meaning. I was astounded. I had no idea so much could go on inside a human being, and wondered if I, too, might find dreams some of the aliveness that Jung had experienced. I had known, in a wordlessly felt way, that something was missing from my life, but I hadn’t had so much as a glancing thought that it could be brought to life within me. Was Jung radically different from me and everyone I knew, or might I, like him, have some internal wellspring that could bubble up in me?

 Dreams happen to us every night without effort or volition, whether we remember them or not. Sometimes dreams wake us up or we awaken to the realization that something has wafted up from within and has an image to convey or a story to tell. I started writing down my “occasional” dreams.

I dreamt I met an author and his friend. We were outdoors “upstate” and the writer was very sad. He wore a necklace with a fish strung head to tail around his neck. I found it special and moving. Then I entered a stone building at the top of the hill we were on. I descended a long flight of zigzag stairs that opened onto a riverbank. People were standing there, and as various boats pulled up—from a ferry to a speedboat—various people boarded. After a while, a man in a red shirt paddling a canoe pulled into shore. I got in with a feeling of anticipation about where we were going.

 And then I woke up. My disappointment bordered on anguish: I had been eager, only to be denied discovery and destination. I felt attracted to the writer and the man paddling the canoe. It felt like a broken promise. I always read a story’s ending before finishing it, unable to bear the suspense of “how it came out” (and curious about how the author would get there). Now I would never know how this story ended.

 But in difficult early adult years I found I could return to the dream: my caring for the author in his sadness…descending the stone stairs, the surprise at the river, choosing the canoe and its guide. I would imagine reaching over the side of the canoe and trailing my hand in the water. This dream was a memory and a promise.

 Many—many–years later I would read Jung’s words: “The spiritual goal toward which the whole nature of man strives is to rescue the light of consciousness…it is the sea to which all rivers went their way…” We are all on the river of life.

 © This Jungian Life 2021

TRY YOUR HAND

When you’ve tried your hand at this month’s exercise, consider  posting it in the corresponding section of the member forum. You’ll have a chance to engage other student’s work and exchange helpful feedback.

Try your hand exercise
Choose a dream you have had that fits one of the categories mentioned in this month’s Discussion. Write a one-page explanation of how and why your dream illustrates this category.

As a reminder, the categories are:

1.  Dreams always tell us something we don’t already know.
2.  Dreams are part of how the psyche self-regulates.
3.  Dreams aid in the individuation process and connect us with the Self.
4.  Dreams help the dreamer create an alliance with and access to the unconscious.
5.  Dreams are the easiest way to access the unconscious.
6.  Dreams support healing and wholeness by building up ego capacity.
7.  Dreams can be diagnostic.
8.  Dreams tell us about projection.
9. Dreams can indicate a corrective to a life course.
10. Dreams provide access to the collective unconscious and emerging myth and meaning.

Reminder: Share your ideas with fellow students on the forum!

Suggested REading

All of the suggested readings from this course will be assigned from four books. You might wish to purchase and read from all four, or you may prefer to use only one or two of the books.

The four books are:

Dreams, A Portal to the Source by Edward C. Whitmont and Sylvia Brinton Perera

Inner Work: Using Dreams and Active Imagination for Personal Growth by Robert A. Johnson

Jungian Dream Interpretation: A Handbook of Theory and Practice by James A. Hall, MD

A Little Course in Dreams: A Basic Handbook of Jungian Dreamwork by Robert Bosnak

 

Here are the suggestions for this module’s reading:

Jungian Dream Interpretation: A Handbook of Theory and Practice by James A. Hall, MD

“A Brief Summing Up,” pp. 116-117

Dreams, A Portal to the Source by Edward C. Whitmont and Sylvia Brinton Perera

pp. 1-4

 

 

extra credit – reading jung

If you’re eager to go straight to the source, we’ll be suggesting key works on dreams from Jung’s writings. We’ll also provide some guidance and context for understanding what you’re reading.

This month, we suggest reading one of Jung’s most important essays on working with dreams:

On the Nature of Dreams  appears in Volume 8 of the Collected Works of C.G. Jung. This essay also appears in the book Dreams  which is published by Princeton University Press and contains most of Jung’s key essays on dream interpretation.

On the Nature of Dreams -- Some Guidance for Reading

On the Nature of Dreams – Some Guidance for Reading

Lisa Marchiano

This is a conversational walk-through of one of Jung’s most important essays on dreams. Unless specified otherwise, paragraph numbers refer to this essay, which appears in Volume 8.

    • Historical Context of this Essay

    It was first published in 1945 and the last edition was in 1948, so this is a later work, more representative of his mature thinking about dreams. We’ll see that in a couple of different ways as we go through this essay, particularly in how he differentiates his theories from Freud’s. This essay also provides perhaps the clearest articulation of his theory of compensation, which we will be talking about today.

    • Causality

    Jung makes this distinction between a “causal” and “final” approach elsewhere. (On Psychic Energy.) This is related to one of his big ideas: that life isn’t just happening to us, it is unfolding. It is going somewhere. It is following some arc, tending toward some goal. This is the idea of telos, and it is relevant both in clinical work generally, as well as in dream work. When someone we are working with is exploring a symptom, it is very important to ask why? Why did this symptom develop? Where do its roots lie? But it is also important to ask the other questions. What do you think this symptom wants of you? Where might it be leading? What is looking to come through you into the world that might be finding expression in this symptom? Such an orientation restores agency, and makes the Self the author of our fate, which we can assist.

    Jung talked about this elsewhere as the mechanistic versus the energic standpoint. The mechanistic view is causal, however the energic standpoint is “final.” “The flow of energy as a definite direction (goal) in that it follows the gradient of potential in a way that cannot be reversed.” (vol. 8, para. 3)

    When working with dreams, the “final” perspective is very important. Especially when people are new to working with dreams, they tend to look for a cause for having had a certain dream. “I think I had that dream because I had just seen that movie three days before,” or “I was reminded of that person the other day, so that’s why she probably showed up in my dream.” Or people interpret the dream to mean something they already know. If they have a dream about their difficult colleague, they say, “The dream is just showing that my colleague is really a pain.” But we wouldn’t have the dream if it were only going to reiterate our conscious standpoint. With dreams, we are always in the realm of the not-yet-consciously-known. That’s the significance of the final approach – what is the new thing that the dream is bringing? Dreams are always revelatory. They show us something new, they lead somewhere we hadn’t yet imagined, even if only in tiny increments.

    “In psychological matters, the question “Why does it happen? Is not necessarily more productive of results than the other question “To what purpose does it happen?” (para. 530)

    Pat Berry recommends asking, when working with dreams, “where is the telos in the dream?” I have found this to be a remarkably helpful question that often refocuses my whole approach when working with a dream. Often an intuitive answer arises. When I think about what it is that comes up when I ask that question, it is usually something like, where is the surprising thing in the dream? The thing that isn’t congruent? The unexpected thing? The thing that doesn’t quite fit?

    • Diagnostic Dreams

    “Since, by virtue of its source in the unconscious, it draws upon a wealth of subliminal perceptions, it can sometimes produce things that are very well worth knowing.” (para. 531)

    This is related to our subject of the final approach. Often, the dream has a sense of where things are going. This is an ordinary, every day kind of knowing, different from pre-cognitive dreams, which in general are rare. It’s important not to overvalue the prognostic or diagnostic function of dreams, but it’s important not to undervalue it either. I have had cases on my practice where the dreams were a reliable indicator of the beginning of a manic phase.

    • Not knowing

    Jung noted that it was important to approach dreams with openness. We have to be comfortable not knowing.

    “So difficult is it to understand a dream that for a long time I have made it a rule, when someone tells me a dream and asks for my opinion, to say first of all to myself: “I have no idea what this dream means.” After that I can begin to examine the dream.” (para. 533).

    • Specificity of dream images

    When seeking associations to dream contents, it matters that we pay attention to the actual images presented to us by the dream maker.

    “If, for instance, someone dreams of a table, we are still far from knowing what the “table” of the dreamer signifies, although the word “table” sounds unambiguous enough.” (para. 539)

    • Context

    Jung credits Freud with placing the dream in the context of the dreamer’s life. Previous approaches to dream interpretation often involved seeing the images in the dream as having a discrete meaning having little reference to the dreamer’s individual psyche.

    “Taking up the context” – “This consists in making sure that every shade of meaning which each salient feature of the dream has for the dreamer is determined by the associations of the dreamer himself.” (para. 542)

    I often try to avoid using the term “association” because it can put people into a very intellectualized place. Instead, I will try to say, “what about X?” It can also be helpful to say “Pretend I know nothing about cars. How would you describe them to me?” Ultimately, we are looking for a brief description that captures the essence of the thing. Sometimes when you ask for associations, people can go off into long stories, but you probably can get enough context from three of four sentences at most. What you are looking for, however, is something that has an emotion in it. You haven’t found the right association, I think, until you have touched upon a feeling.

    When working with a difficult to interpret dream, you can go through each element and get the associations. Ideally, at the end of this exercise, you have emotionally significant brief descriptions for each element.

    Jung makes the point that going through the context can be painstaking and methodical. Like other methodical processes, it is a good place to start when, upon hearing a dream, our mind goes blank and we have no ideas. Sometimes we hear a dream and immediately have a sense of what it might mean, or at least what it might be about. But at least as often, we hear a dream and are obliged to think, along with Jung, “I have no idea what this means.” Then, fortunately, we have the methodical work of going through the context to guide us an get us started. The context won’t reveal the meaning in and of itself. For that, our symbolic and emotional imagination will be required.

    “It needs psychological empathy, ability to coordinate, intuition, knowledge of the world and of men, and above all a special “canniness” which depends on wide understanding as well as a certain intelligence du Coeur.” (para. 543)

    Hopefully, the context gives you a hint. Something jumps out at you. Your intuition turns on and makes some connection or prompts a question. Some pattern suggests itself to you.

    Specifics:

    Following are some specific issues that come up when examining the context.

    The dream setting and the context around it can be very helpful for knowing what general area we are in. For example, if the dream takes place at work, it is likely about the dreamer’s work life. Bedroom, backyard, childhood home.

    Actors or celebrities: When actors turn up in dreams, I find it useful to ask about the roles the actor has played. The meaning in the dream usually refers to the roles the actor has played, rather than the actor himself.

    Feelings: For me, the feelings associated with particular dream images or dream sequences matter a great deal in understanding a dream. Though sometimes the feeling is obvious, (e.g. chase dreams are frightening), the exact emotion can be very informative. For example, for some dreams in which the manifest content is quite frightening, if you ask the person says, yes, it was scary, but not terrifying.

    Jung was in agreement with me as to the importance of feelings.

    “I want to emphasize that it is not safe to interpret a dream without going into careful detail as to the context. Never apply any theory, but always ask the patient how he feels about his dream-images.” (CW 18 par. 218).

    “Even if one has great experience in these matters, one is again and again obliged, before each dream, to admit one’s ignorance and, renouncing all preconceived ideas, to prepare for something entirely unexpected.” (para 543)

    • Autonomy of the Unconscious

    The unconscious has a different standpoint from that of the conscious mind, and a major function of dreams is to point out to us what the unconscious thinks of the conscious attitude. One good question to ask when working with a dream is, what does the dream maker think about the conscious attitude?

    • Compensation

    Jung called this function compensation. Dream as compensation is in some ways the cornerstone of Jung’s theory of dreams. It clearly differentiates how he sees dreams functioning from Freud’s theory of dreams as disguised wishes.

    In 1934 Jung wrote: “Every process that goes too far immediately and inevitably calls forth compensation”, and that, “[t]he theory of compensation is a basic law of psychic behavior […] When we set out to interpret a dream, it is always helpful to ask: What conscious attitude does it compensate (Vol. 16, The Practical Use of Dream Analysis, para. 330)

    “Compensation…means balancing and comparing different points of view so as to produce an adjustment or rectification.” (para. 545)

    Compensation essentially means that dream supply that which is missing. In general, dreams will present us with an image that is as out of balance in one direction as the conscious attitude is out of balance in the other direction. This is why dreams “overstate” things and present us with images that seem very dramatic. They are trying to balance out a conscious attitude that is listing the opposite direction.

    • Divergence between the conscious and unconscious attitudes

    Paragraph 546 is highly significant, because here Jung offers both a definition and an explanation for neurosis. “These disturbances are due to a lack of harmony between conscious and unconscious.” Dreams are important, then, because they reveal the discordance between the conscious and unconscious attitudes, and in fact aim to restore balance. This is how dreams promote psychic health and point us toward individuation.

    And this brings us to another big idea.

    • The psyche as a self-regulating system

    The psyche aims to rebalance itself, and dreams are one of the major ways that it does so. This is such an important idea – maybe the single most important idea. Think about the implications of this, and how it differs so dramatically from other schools of thought around mental health!

    • How dreams heal

    “They do, however, illuminate the patient’s situation in a way that can be exceedingly beneficial to health. They bring him memories, insights, experiences, awaken dormant qualities in the personality, and reveal the unconscious element in his relationships. So it seldom happens that anyone who has taken the trouble to work over his dreams with qualified assistance for a longer period of time remains without enrichment and a broadening of his mental horizon. Just because of their compensatory behavior, a methodical analysis of dreams discloses new points of view and new ways of getting over the dreaded impasse.” (para. 549)

    • Dreams contribute to the development of the personality

    What Jung is saying here is that each dream nudges us in a direction – just incrementally. But there is an overall plan – we’re back to the idea of telos. And of course, he is talking here about individuation. He refers to it as a “planned and orderly process of development,” (para. 550). If you think about the implications of that phrase for a minute, you realize something important about how Jung saw individuation – that it is a directed process toward an end that is already perceived or known by some deep part of us.

    This paragraph also makes an important link between compensation and individuation. Compensation is, as it were, the unconscious’s way of nudging back on our path, keeping us moving towards the end that it somehow knows to be the right one.

    • Big dreams

    These are archetypal dreams that come from the collective layer of the unconscious rather than the merely personal. K’s dream of the Mexican goddess. These are always accompanied by a very strong emotion. Personal context is not useful when interpreting archetypal elements of dreams.

    “All these moments in the individual’s life, when the universal laws of human fate break in upon the purposes, expectations, and opinions of the personal consciousness, are stations along the road of the individuation process.” (para. 557)

    Decisive moments in a person’s life are likely to give rise to archetypal or “big” dreams.

    An analysand brought in a dream that she experienced as deeply affecting at a time of deep distress and peril. This was very clearly a “big dream. In paragraph 555, Jung states that “the big or meaningful dreams come from this deeper level [the collective unconscious.]” The dream of my analysand drew on mythological imagery previously consciously unknown to either myself or the patient. With the patient’s permission, here is the dream:

    A young, 20-something-ish woman is in the dream. She is foreign, possibly from an Eastern European country, and is very fair-skinned and slender. She is staying or living in a house that belongs to someone I know slightly. When I first see her she is wearing a white t-shirt with some sort of design on it, but no underwear, nothing else. Her pubic hair is entirely shaved; the whole area is very pale and entirely visible. I feel startled and somewhat disgusted. Someone tells me, later on I think, that this woman eats her own feces as some sort of health or sexual practice. I feel more disgusted, repelled. But the woman is also compelling and it’s interesting to me that she is so beautiful; she has a sort of pure, innocent look about her, and very milk-white skin.

    Upon hearing the dream, I fell under the influence of its haunting mood. The imagery was provocative and full of feeling, but I had no sense of where to begin to pull it apart, so I did something that I don’t often do. After checking to make sure it was okay with my patient, I pulled out The Book of Symbols and looked up the entry for “feces”. Both of us were struck by the aptness of the symbol to her personal experience and situation. I was amazed to find such a close parallel between this patient’s imagery and a mythology totally foreign to her. This parallel called to mind Jung’s theory, and made it seem more than merely theoretical.

    Below is the passage I read to my patient:

    “The filth that the goddess Tlazolteotl is seen endlessly swallowing and excreting in Aztec codices paradoxically polluted and purified her, for her own bodily waste emerged as a flower, a Central American glyph symbolizing female sensuality and, by suggestion, childbirth, over which she presided. The human waste that Aztecs collected to fertilize their fields decayed into humus or tlazollalli (“earth filth”) that they believed generated in her bowels in the subterranean land of the dead, an unspeakable place that ironically gave birth to life-sustaining corn. Her name derives from the root tlazolli, meaning not just filth, but also vice and disease, since the Aztecs confessed their sexual misdeeds to her on their deathbeds, shameful stories that she greedily consumed in the form of excrement. The Aztec’s word for disgrace literally meant to be smeared in excrement, yet their words for “gold” meant “divine excrement” or “the sun’s excrement.” With similar paradox, alchemy claimed, and psychology supports, that the gold of transformation “is found in filth,” in the very aspects of one’s substance the ego tends to dismiss as inferior.”

    My patient was at a critical juncture in her life just at the moment that she had this dream. Like many women, she had suffered a lifetime of shame and disgust about her body and sexuality. She had long expressed a desire to heal this wound, but did not know how to go about doing so. At the point when this dream occurred, she was in a very dark and vulnerable place. She was considering opening herself up to new sexual experiences, but at the same time, on a conscious level she was convinced that no positive outcome would be possible were she to do so.

    The psyche presented a solution to this dilemma in the form of this dream, which avails itself of Aztec imagery. The shit-eating, purifying goddess invoked in the dream addressed precisely the psychic challenge faced by my patient at that time. The archetypal energy awakened at this critical time in her life was capable of transforming her self-disgust and shame about her body and her sexuality, and using this as fertile material to give birth to new life of the highest value (gold). For my patient, the dream showed the possibility of a process of purification, a redemption of the female body and sexuality from shame through a process of consuming and digesting precisely that thing that has long been held as most repulsive.

    • Do dreams need to be interpreted?

    Jung offers us a heartening answer to this question.

    “It is often objected that the compensation must be ineffective unless the dream is understood. This is not so certain, however, for many things can be effective without being understood. But there is no doubt that we can enhance its effect considerably by understanding the dream, and this is often necessary because the voice of the unconscious so easily goes unheard.” (para. 560)

    • Don’t overvalue the unconscious

    Jung was always careful to warn against overvaluing the unconscious. “Experience has shown me that a slight knowledge of dream psychology is apt to lead to an overrating of the unconscious which impairs the power of conscious decision.” (para. 568)

     

     

    © This Jungian Life 2021

     

CLICK HERE FOR FULL CHAPTER

DReamatorium: Module 1

We invite you to read the dream below, share your thoughts, and post your interpretation in the Member Forum.

This month’s dreamer is a 34-year-old female who works as a psychologist.

Dream Module 1

I was walking along a pier holding the hand of my 4 year old daughter. The pier was unusual as it was T-shaped. It went out into a body of water; I think a lake. I noticed I was wearing a white bath towel and thought this was strange as I’d usually bring a beach towel if I was going for a swim. When we reached the end of the pier (the part where you could turn left or right; it was unclear what was in either direction) I noticed my ex in the water with a friend. The section of water he was in seemed to be sectioned off with a shark net. He saw me and threw me an orange. I was surprised but I caught it. I didn’t say anything. I turned right and walked off with my daughter carrying the orange.

Feelings in the dream: surprise and curiosity

Context and Associations: Ex was someone I dated 10 years ago, haven’t had any contact. My daughter is currently 4 yrs old.